I just spoke with Odyssey again. Some girl named Shelly? (1-800-964-2837)
I explained to her my situation. She plainly told me that something would have to be seriously wrong with my electrical system to have two failures, because they get less than 1% failure rate. She told me I would not get my battery replaced.
I asked why.
Her: Because your electrical system has to have something wrong with it.
Me: Wouldn't you have to determine the cause of failure first, before sticking me with it?
Her: Yes, but you would have to pay for it, and it more than likely is your fault.
Me: ???
I told her my boat doesn't have a charging system, that it has a total loss ignition. Total disbelief on her part. My external charger must be the problem. I try to explain to her that the charger meets their specs.
She says she'd have to talk to tech support, but it's more than likely my fault, and I won't get a replacement.
I was also informed that no Odyssey dealer is required to honor the warranty.
I asked her why the warranty statement doesn't tell me this. (In fact, the warranty states to take it to any Odyssey dealer for replacement and that it will be replaced if it's defective due to workmanship/quality, etc)
I specifically asked if the warranty statement is untrue then. I was told the same thing over.
She said she will call the BatteriesPlus store and talk to them (only to get them to do an autopsy on the battery at my expense).
Oh, by the way: She told me that before any warranty replacement, the battery has to be tested, and that the customer gets charged for that!
I am done and through with Odyssey. I will include a link to this thread in my signature from now on.
Don't just stay away from them, RUN from them.