Whats a good compression guage?

jetskiking

Im done sanding!!!
Location
Dallas Georgia
Now that I have your attention.Use an air compressor to test your compression guage. I just see alot of posts about compression guages and wether its a cheap one or not. Maybe there are just alot of Snap-on tool reps here. A cheap one is fine just check it. Its not rocket science.
 

michael950

for me to POOP on!
Location
Houston, TX
Group-K Website:
Group K said:
THE GAUGE - Most engine builders have a drawer in their rollaway dedicated to storing all the "cheap compression gauges" that they have used the poor judgment to buy during their career. However in the very front of that drawer is the Snap-On gauge that gets used regularly. This gauge is preferred not just for it's good accuracy and durability, but rather for one simple design feature. The adaptor hoses, of the Snap-On gauge, that screw into the spark plug threads has a Schrader air fitting at the spark plug tip location. That is, the pressure is sealed off at the face of the dome in the cylinder head, which gives the truest representation of the exact combustion chamber volume. Most other automotive gauges have this air seal fitting mounted in the gauge body, at the end of a 16" hose. This means that the air volume inside that hose (usually about 3-4 cc) is added to the combustion chamber volume during a measurement. The end result of his added volume is a reading that is 20 - 35 psi lower than the true reading. For similar reasons, the tapered rubber "hold - on" type gauges are virtually useless. Besides indicating the added 2 cc of the threaded spark plug hole itself, these gauges are notorious for leaking as well.

COMPRESSION RATIOS & MEASUREMENT
 

michael950

for me to POOP on!
Location
Houston, TX
OK, I just read the post (went off the title and posted a reply)...

I wondered the same thing, but I think accuracy is the reason most buy snap-on.
 

jetskiking

Im done sanding!!!
Location
Dallas Georgia
When you get right down to it a compression check isnt accurate anyway and used mostly for comparison. Also I dont see how having the valve on the end of the hose is any different it still has to compress the air in the hose to register on the guage. It just sounds like the thousands of sales ploys used to confuse people and justify there overpriced tools. I do agree that you need a screw in type to get the best reading. I figured out along time ago that you dont always get what you pay for. I'm sure snap-on dosn't even make guages. Can anyone tell me where the snap-on guage manufacturing plant is? So that tells me someone else makes it. Who else do they make them for? If you just want the best of everything then snap-on is the stuff to have, but I'm just saying that there are other quality alternatives and that the guage can be checked to make sure its accurate.
 

Mouthfulloflake

ISJWTA member #2
Location
NW Arkansas
If snap-on has a lifetime warranty on the Compression tester, and craftsman doesn't... I will buy snap-on

why?

thats like lifetime brake pads, or a lifetime warranty on a starter motor.

you are paying for potential replacements down the road, and NOT any superior quality. ( this is USUALLY the case)

some one post the internal workings of a snap on compression guage, Ill tear my 10 year old cheapy apart and post pics of its guts, lets take bets on how much they differ.
 

ski4

gonzo
Location
cleveland
i am curious about this hose theory as well, a hose is a hose no matter where the pressure relief valve is i could see if it was made with no hose then we have another animal to compare

seems with the vavle on top it may actually be a better way, or maybe i am just tired
 

cookerq62

Life's Been Good
Location
Upper Bucks, PA
My $22 wal-mart comp gauge has the valve at the end of the hose by the head. I Doubt the reading it gives is accurate relative to what my actual compression is. It is precise enough to tell me if something is up with the motor and that’s all I really have it for.
 

meatball

User Title Unavailable
Location
Maryland
I have a push in compression gauge that cost like 20 bucks, generic, and its always been accurate (150 in doubles and 120 in twins).

And a lot of people say not to get a non-thread style or a cheap one. I agree with you here, its comparison.
 
Top Bottom