Maybe I'm a jerk but I say no way... I know you ran that engine for quite a while before you actually melted the piston. The buyer melted at least 2 top ends in less than 5 months. I think it's safe to say that something he is doing is way wrong. If he didn't bother to inspect everything after the first meltdown, that puts him at fault for anything else that may have crapped out.
Everything you buy on a forum, ebay, or craigslist is considered as-is. If it's broken when it gets to your doorstep, that's the sellers problem. If it breaks after it's been used, that's the buyers problem. The fact that you bought him one top end after 5 months is way beyond what most companies would've done for a brand new engine.